NYC’s Trustworthy Source for Insurance Needs for over Fifty Years
212.406.7300 |

Claims & Billing

If you are a current Gotham Brokerage Co., Inc., customer wishing to submit a claim or make a billing inquiry, you may contact us for advice and information and/or contact your insurance carrier directly.

For your convenience, the contact information for Gotham’s most popular carriers follows. Call us if you are unsure whom to call or how to call to file your claim.

Claims: 1.800.252.4633
Personal (home, auto, umbrella, valuable items) billing inquiries: 1.877.878.2468
Commercial (business) billing questions: 1.800.252.2268

Claims: 1.800.252.4670
Billing inquiries: 1.800.682.4822

Auto Policy Service (including claims): 1.800.PROGRESSIVE (1.800.776.4737)

Remember, Gotham Brokerage is your advocate! If you are unsatisfied with the service you are getting from your insurance carrier, please don’t hesitate to contact your Gotham representative.