NYC’s Trustworthy Source for Apartment Insurance
212.406.7300 |

About Us

New York City’s Trusted Source for Insurance Needs for More Than Fifty Years

Photo courtesy of Scott Hudson

We didn’t just fall off the bagel truck.

We know the New York Metro area inside and out. From Westchester to Weehawken, from Syosset to Stamford, we’ve been serving the demanding needs of residents and business owners in the Tri-state New York area for more than 50 years.

We specialize in apartment and homeowners insurance coverage for co-ops, apartments, rentals and all types of homes. Although we focus on New York City buildings in Manhattan, Brooklyn and Queens, we provide coverage for customers in NY, NJ, CT and PA.

We help New Yorkers as they grow and their needs change. Moving from an apartment to your first home? Buying a vacation home? Moving to the suburbs? We’ve got you and your family covered.

Gotham Brokerage Company, Inc., is a top-quality insurance firm. We’re state licensed and a long-standing member the Professional Insurance Agents of New York. In addition, we have an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau.

We represent a large array of the finest insurance carriers and because we are not tied to one insurance brand, we can often deliver better coverage at hard-to-beat rates.

We offer smart, comprehensive and competitively priced insurance solutions, including:

As a family-run company, we’ve built a business by understanding, caring about, and responding to the unique living and working situations of New Yorkers.

Our insurance solutions are customized to cover you thoroughly and practically. Each Gotham agent boasts more than 20 years average experience in the insurance industry.

You get savvy solutions at the best possible value.

Most importantly, you get personal service and just the right coverage you need so that when you really need it, it is there.

Want to read more?

Take some time to learn about insurance issues in NYC by reading our blog articles:

New York Times: Why New Yorkers are 50% More Likely to Get Burglarized

What You Need to Know About Insuring Your Jewelry

Tips on Shopping for Renters Insurance in New York City